Growth Commission Report Sidelines Working Class Scotland

Photo: Craig Maclean

by Ken Ferguson

The so-called Growth Commission report is a dismal document which confirms the reality that the SNP is firmly wedded to neoliberal, pro market economics which are failing on a daily basis both here and across the world.

Throughout the document this point is reinforced – none more so when they talk of “fiscal responsibility”; code for keeping the city of London and the markets happy.

What this means in reality for Scotland’s working class – who make up the majority of society – is that the squeeze on spending, services, jobs and wages will continue for at least a decade while the financial elites decide that we are well behaved enough to borrow their money.

This is one of the key areas that First Minister Sturgeon meant when she told Radio 4 that some choices cannot be “sugar coated.”

Placating Profiteers

A sample page from the report – which lays bare the austerity economics at its heart.

In plain English while we placate the profiteers, little will change for the million Scots in poverty, the tens of thousands desperate to escape greedy landlords, those on poverty pay and in insecure jobs.

Brutally this report doesn’t concern itself with their problems, but has been crafted by a blinkered elite of policy wonks to serve the purpose of spiking unionist guns and keeping the markets calm.

Entirely predictably, it fails on both counts as the same establishment who mobilised and supported Better Together raise the same objections ably assisted by a largely pliant pro-unionist media. In an event as predictable as the arrival of summer swallows – Radio 4s flagship World at One programme covered the document’s launch with a brief interview with First Minister Sturgeon, and then a piece at least 4 times longer by Scots Tory chief (and ex-BBC hack) Ruth Davidson.

Working Class Majority Needed

However from the perspective of the wider independence movement this document has a much more serious flaw at its heart.

The SSP are firmly of the view that winning Scotland’s working class majority to a Yes vote is the key to victory and this will only be achieved by policies and a vision which meet the needs and aspirations of that class. In this document they hardly merit a passing mention.

It as if solutions to poverty, insecure work, poor public transport, low pay and the housing crisis among a myriad of challenges don’t exist.

Unsurprisingly this report is already becoming the subject of a politicians and commentariat bun-fight as the same self selecting circle rehearse the same stale points on the same radio and TV shows and in the same pages of the hysterical unionist press.

[x_pullquote type=”right”]The 45% who voted Yes in 2014 was largely built on the prospects of a radically changed just Scotland, not a mini pro-market UK.[/x_pullquote]Rather than yet another politicians talk-in; working class voters who have been subject to ten long years of austerity need action – not the prospect of a further ten years of cuts badged as “fiscal responsibility’.

People and Planet First

It is a truism that actions speak louder than words and there is plenty of scope for action which would both deal with needs of working class Scotland and offer a vision of what more could be achieved with independence which put people and planet first.

Waiting the Glasgow Result in 2014 – Photo: Craig Maclean

The 45% who voted Yes in 2014 was largely built on the prospects of a radically changed just Scotland, not a mini pro-market UK. Any advance on that support needs to offer radical alternatives to working class No voters. They are the key to victory.

In any debate around the report and in subsequent campaigning, the Scottish Socialist Party will present our vision of a different Scotland. One which breaks with the failed pro-market approach of the SNP and other major parties. These parties efforts have together produced a society of zero hours contracts, a million Scots in poverty and criminally exploitative landlordism.

Photo: Craig Maclean

We need action now to ensure a £10 an hour wage for all rising with inflation, a guaranteed minimum working week of 16 hours, a massive rented housing programme and an extension of public ownership to include railways and energy becomes a reality.

This would point the way, like a searchlight, to what a radically different independent Scotland could achieve.

In contrast, the SNP’s document fails to illuminate how independence would open a future which meets need, not elite greed.

3 thoughts on “Growth Commission Report Sidelines Working Class Scotland

  1. Wilson’s plan for austerity and recession after independence is a match for Sturgeon’s austerity and low growth policies today – her bad deal austerity fiscal framework agreement with the UK Tory government.

    The fastest “growth” in Scotland right now is Sturgeon’s over-inflated ego and it is about time that the SNP and independence movement asked Sturgeon to resign to make way for a new First Minister who can grow Scotland’s economy and bring prosperity to our people.

    Peter Dow
    Science and Politics

  2. They are still and will be tartan tories but the only game in town at mo. I’ll take Indy any way I can get it then vote for a people’s party.

    1. I’m no less committed to independence, but the Yes movement has got to be smarter.

      If this is the economic and political prospectus we offer the Scottish people – one which promises further austerity, after ten years of the Tories and New Labour after the finance crash – we will lose a second referendum.

      And like Canada, which lost two referendums on the subject, you can forget about a third in any of our lifetimes.

Comments are closed.