By Richie Venton, SSP National Workplace Organiser
The long-awaited, carefully leaked, Labour government-backed Milburn Report on the million under-25s who are not in employment, education or training (so-called ‘NEETS’) has been tarted up as a new ‘Youth Opportunity Service’ to “help young people into work or training”, but is rife with assaults on their incomes.
It’s been hailed by Andy Burnham as “a watershed in supporting young people into work and training”.
Whilst Milburn and Burnham ooze out reassurances that they agree “young people don’t lack aspirations, but lack opportunities”, they promise jam tomorrow in a ten-year plan, but threats to young people’s benefits in the immediate future.
In their claims to “reset the system” to counter the waste of a generation, it’s not so much carrot and stick, more a limp lettuce and hardwood club!
Learning from Starmer’s disability cuts
When Keir Starmer blundered into a scattergun attack on disability benefits, the public outcry forced him to retreat and terminally damaged his authority as Prime Minister.
Learning from that, Burnham’s re-decorated Labour have softened up public opinion with pretty words about “believing in young people” and not carrying out “crude cuts” to their benefits, wishing to “support” 440,000 young people into work or education by 2036.
Milburn: the man behind the plan
From the outset, it’s worth noting the credentials of the report’s author, to get a glimpse of what lies behind the honeyed phrases of concern for what is undoubtedly a lost generation.
Alan Milburn was an arch Blairite New Labour MP and Cabinet Minister from 1992-2010, during which time he zealously supported Blair’s illegal invasion of Iraq, and helped spearhead the marketization of our National Health Service through the calamitous PFI schemes, which steal at least £5 from taxpayers for every £1 invested in hospitals by private capitalist consortia.
He went on to lend his services as an advisor on child poverty and social mobility to David Cameron’s Tory government, which presided over increased child poverty and expanded inequality between the classes in society.
Hardly the CV of a man to be trusted with tackling the life crisis of over a million young people in the UK!
‘Youth Opportunity Service’
Milburn’s report recommends a Youth Opportunity Service (YOS) in England, under the control of its metropolitan mayors and councils, with guarantees of a meeting with an advisor within two weeks of a young person contacting the YOS; a “participation plan” of steps to employment,
training or education within one month; “substantive moves” to securing a place at college or an apprenticeship within four months – all of which is coated in sugary language about “support”, but which past experience teaches will involve pressure to drive young people off benefits into menial, dead-end jobs, regardless of their suitability.
Savage benefits cuts
That fear is well-founded when the proposals on benefits are studied. People under 25 would no longer get the health element of Universal Credit, nor PIP for disabled people, in England. These would be replaced by a Youth Allowance set at the basic rate of Universal Credit: £338-a-month for a single person and £528 per month for those living with a partner.
In stark facts and figures, that means the loss of over £200-a-month in their income for those on the lower rate of disability benefits, and over £420-a-month for young people currently on the higher rate of payment for sickness, disability and conditions like autism, ADHD and dyspraxia.
To sugar the pill, two new schemes are proposed: a Health and Disability Fund purely for one-off or unexpected costs, and a Severe and Complex Needs Insurance (higher than the current PIP allowance) for “those who will never work due to profound disabilities”.
One of the crunch questions which arise is who determines whether somebody qualifies for these additional payments.
Targeting neurodivergent and disabled young people
As I have repeatedly warned in articles and speeches over recent months, Milburn’s Report has been consciously accompanied by a rising crescendo of alleged experts proclaiming “over-diagnosis” of conditions like anxiety, depression, autism and ADHD.
And sure enough, on the day of Milburn’s Report, this same claim was again wheeled out in the media, in a cynical divide-and-conquer manoeuvre – to try and get the general public make a distinction between physical and mental ill health, or more specifically to demonise neurodivergent young people… as if they are inventing a neurological condition they were born with in order to dodge work.
A filthy history of demonisation
This demonization of a minority follows on in the footsteps of a pernicious tradition going back to the Means Tests of a century ago; the late Labour Minister Frank Field’s Victorian-style propaganda about ‘the deserving and undeserving poor’; the Blair government’s demonization of single parents before cutting their benefits; the decision by the Lib Dem/Tory coalition of Cameron and Clegg to end state payment of student tuition fees, and their vilification of disabled people as “shirkers”, imposing ‘fit for work’ tests carried out by privatised firms which set themselves targets for the numbers to fail; the more recent exclusion of pensioners not on other government benefits from Winter Fuel Payments, warm-home insulation and heating schemes; and Burnham’s plan to dismantle the Triple Lock on state pensions, despite two million retired people in the UK already officially living below the poverty line.
Bribery of the bosses
We can be certain the Labour government will pursue the punitive benefits cuts component of this report.
Likewise, it’s a safe bet they will adopt the programme of barefaced bribery to employers which it advocates. For example, it proposes a £3,000 handout to an employer hiring a young person who’s been out of work or training for six months, increased to £5,000 of bribery to smaller businesses. And payment by the government of 25 hours-a-week of wages for 6 months, if a boss takes on a young person who’s been a ‘NEET’ for a year.
It recommends that in retail and hospitality – which are the most common entry points for young workers – the employers’ National Insurance threshold be raised from £5,000 to £10,000 for anyone aged 21-24, making it cheaper to employ them. It also promises a gradual reduction in employers’ NIC contributions across the board for employing young people.
In total, it offers over £6 billion in state handouts to private capitalist employers who are busy slashing their workforces, in many cases dodging taxes, and handing out dividends to big shareholders. If such sums were given to workers, pensioners, or those on some form of social security payments, it would be roundly decried by ‘centre party’ politicians and the media as rewarding ‘scroungers.’
Lurking threats to wages and workplace rights
Behind the reassuring mood music, Milburn let slip the more vicious intentions in how they aim to drive young people off benefits into jobs, in his interview on the BBC Today programme. Asked if the level of the youth minimum wage and (slightly) improved workplace rights regulations is a barrier to youth employment, Milburn responded, “Yes, in future the government must be cautious about the convergence of the youth minimum wage with the adult rate, and also cautious about workplace regulations.”
So, the bosses are to be bribed, but young people bullied into cheap-labour jobs – with no guarantees of them lasting more than a few months – on pain of losing their benefits; ultimately all their benefits, if they decline such offers.
Milburn and Burnham regularly reassure us “there will be no crude cuts to benefit”; only very refined, sophisticated ones, we must assume!
We want genuine youth guarantees – without compulsion
Any parent or decent human being, let alone a socialist, will grieve at and condemn the terrible waste of young talent in our society.
They will want a state which guarantees school-leavers either a place in further and higher education; an apprenticeship with the guarantee of a decent, fulfilling job at the end; or meaningful work which provides a decent income and boosts the self-esteem and confidence of young workers. But not by cruel cuts to the benefits of those who cannot find a job or college place – or live with conditions which mean they need vastly improved mental health services, adjustments at work, with proper support and mentorship by sympathetic, experienced workers who take them under their wing.
But despite the 278-page length of this report, there is no plan to create meaningful, well-paid jobs. And its talk of doubling the number of apprenticeships 10 years hence (in 2036) and expanding further education college places in England by 150,000 places – through collaboration between mayors and businesses – is not backed up by any plan of state intervention to achieve such a land of milk and honey.
Where are the jobs?
Currently 2.5 unemployed people apply for every single job vacancy – and employers get 140 applicants for every graduate job they advertise. The very same day the Milburn report was published, the number of job vacancies fell by 22,000 in the previous quarter. The same report recounted that hospitality and retail are especially reluctant to hire young people, with the standard excuse that “they lack experience and cost too much, so why not employ older workers?”
Across the UK, there are 250,000 more unemployed young people than there are total job vacancies. And thinking the other 750,000 ‘NEETS’ could therefore get a job if they weren’t so idle and disinclined – as the right-wing media and mainstream politicians tell us – ignores the fact there are plenty of people OVER 25 also searching for what jobs exist. In fact, there are about 8 million fewer vacancies than jobseekers!
These stubborn facts demolish the underlying assumption that the young people they disparagingly label ‘NEETS’ just can’t be bothered getting work, when as one young woman said, “I hate the term NEETS, we should be called DEETS, desperate for employment, education or training.”
The problem is capitalism, not young people
The one million 18 to 24-year-olds outside formal learning or earning are not the cause of a crisis in society, but the victims.
They have been failed by a capitalist class – and their kept, pet governments of all stripes – who have refused to reinvest profit from the unpaid labour of the working class into the modernization of industry and services.
A society and tax system which incentivises rent-racketeering and property speculation, rather than investment in housebuilding, energy production, care services, or any other essentials to the lives of millions.
Capitalism = working ‘til you drop!
A society that forces increased numbers of older people to continue working for a wage to survive, long after what used to be state retirement age, because of the pitiful levels of state pension (one of the lowest in Europe), thereby further reducing job prospects for younger people.
A capitalist society which relies on chronic levels of unemployment to batter down wages; where young people apply for hundreds of jobs and either don’t even get a reply let alone an interview, or only a demoralising rejection slip generated by AI.
No wonder there is an escalating epidemic of mental ill health, anxiety and depression – in a capitalist world where we’re told “there is no such thing as society”, that individualism and dog-eat-dog competition is the only acceptable religion, which adds to the isolation, low self-esteem and despair that is all too common.
Work to be done – but no jobs created
There is a vast amount of work to be done to turn Scotland and the UK into a society fit for the 21st century.
We need to hire an army of health and care staff, well trained and well paid, to expand preventative healthcare and treat an ageing population.
The housing emergency in Scotland requires building at least 100,000 eco-friendly council houses for affordable rent, and a mass, systematic retrofit of existing homes, free of charge, to combat fuel poverty and climate-wrecking emissions.
For free public transport & green energy
A publicly owned, expanded, accessible, free public transport network – green-powered and integrated – would radically reduce both poverty and car pollution, enhancing the lives of millions, and would require tens of thousands of new jobs and apprenticeships. Studies have shown at least 60,000 new jobs in Scotland could thus be created in the transport sector.
Likewise, at least 70,000 new jobs and apprenticeships could be created in a rapid transition to green energy production and distribution, cutting bills, pollution and the ‘climate anxiety’ that adds to the mental distress of particularly younger people.
Expand colleges – instead of slashing funding
The skills, trades and upskilling required in the construction industry, energy, public transport, care services, etc, would require massive investment and expansion of further education colleges and universities, with the educators’ jobs that would ensue. But instead of travelling down that path, both the UK and Scottish governments preside over systematic cuts to public services.
That austerity includes a 20% cut to funding for Scotland’s FE colleges since 2021, with a 20% reduction in student intake, and 13% cut in staffing levels – plus a crisis of underfunding and mismanagement in universities.
Socialist Green New Deal
A Socialist Green New Deal built on the foundations of democratic public ownership – with workers’ control- of energy, public transport, construction, banking, landed estates and all technologies (including Artificial Intelligence) could create at least 350,000 new jobs and apprenticeships in Scotland. That’s what could be on offer if a plan of socialist change was pursued.
That is certainly not on offer from Burnham’s Labour, nor Milburn’s Report.
Will the SNP go down Milburn’s road?
Will the SNP government travel a different road?
They certainly can do so, if they have the political will and ideology to confront the continuity neo-liberalism of Burnham’s Labour, camouflaged by a dictionary of warm words and fairy tales.
This Milburn Report is almost exclusively about England. Scotland isn’t even mentioned – and then only in the passing – until page 93 of this 278-page tome, and again alongside the other devolved governments on page 193!
What Milburn has declared to be “the biggest employment support package for employers and businesses in 50 years “- barefaced bribery from public funds to private capital, in other words! – does apply to Scotland. The rest of the package, including benefit cuts, does not – unless the Scottish Government decide to imitate the actions of Milburn and Burnham.
Defend and improve devolved benefits!
PIP payments to the disabled in England have been devolved and replaced by Adult Disability Payments in Scotland. This makes up half of Scotland’s entire welfare budget.
But this is where we should beware: the Scottish Fiscal Commission have warned of a £1.2 billion funding gap by 2030/1 for Scotland’s devolved Social Security spending. And last year, Audit Scotland criticised the Scottish Government for failing to set out long-term plans on how to fund Adult Disability Payments.
Given the ideological convergence of the SNP leadership with Burnham’s Labour on most other issues, it will require mass pressure to guarantee Holyrood does not travel down the same road of benefit cuts to bludgeon young people into menial, dead-end jobs, regardless of the impact on their well-being.
The SSP stands up for young people
At its annual conference last weekend, the Scottish Socialist Party anticipated these issues, unanimously adopting a policy motion entitled Welfare not Warfare.
It committed the SSP to joint struggle with youth organisations, trade unionists, pensioners’ campaigns and disabled people’s organisations to demand:
“A guaranteed job, apprenticeship, training, or education for every school-leaver, with a guaranteed minimum wage of £15-an-hour from the age of 16 upwards, or an equivalent living grant at 16 to make education genuinely accessible to the working class… rejecting any attempts to cut the health element of benefits, which would be purely designed to compel sick, disabled or neurodivergent people into jobs without proper support and adjustments… for increases to benefits to match the real cost of living a dignified life; massive expansion of apprenticeships, training and education under workers’ control, as part of a Socialist Green New Deal; and massive state investment in the expansion of services for sick, disabled and neurodivergent people and their families, rather than punishment through benefits cuts.”
For a fulfilling future through socialist change
The subsequent publication of Labour’s plans makes this all the more important as a fighting alternative to attacks on young people disguised as ‘tough love’.
We need to prepare action to stop the Scottish government being tempted to try the same.
We need united action – by all generations – to give young people a secure and fulfilling future.
The best way to win such meaningful ‘youth opportunities’ is through socialist change, which this Report makes the SSP even more determined to fight for, alongside and within all generations of the working class.

